Sunday, September 10, 2006

Tuesday's class upcoming

After having has strong look in lecture Thursday of important major thematic aspects of The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie, on Tuesday we will go over some specific close-reading points from in lecture, and then in seminar make sure that the various distinct elements presented are understood as a cohesive unity: the double picture of Brodie, 1932 fascism, Calvisnism, Scotland and identity, and Edinburgh-ism.

Film Version of "Prime of Miss Jean Brodie"

I looked at a copy of the film this weekend, and my memory had replaced Alec Guinness for Gordon Jackson -- sorry for the confusion. I remember Jackson from one of my favourite Avengers episodes, Castle De'ath, as well as a co-star with Steve McQueen in The Great Escape, but most famously of course the character of the butler Mr. Hudson in the BBC's Upstairs Downstairs.

We'll discuss the significant change in emphasis from the book to the film adaptation, using one important scence, in class this week.

Thursday, September 07, 2006

The Proclaimers "Throw the 'R' Away"

Here are the lyrics to The Proclaimers' song we heard in the opening lecture. Note that the song is an expression of nationalism: i.e. antipathy to another's nation, to wit England, rather than a simple affirmation of a national virtue of one's own. For example, the comment "perhaps for some money ..." is a shot at England's amusement at Scots' extreme thrift.


Wednesday, September 06, 2006

"Doubleness" in Scots Literature

To examples given in lecture of the critical commonplace notion of "Doubleness" in Scotland --
a debilitatingly fractured culture chracterised by an infamous doubleness, a conception that has ‘constrained Scottish criticism in its insistence on the idea of a tradition defined by internal oppositions', and of Scottishness as a ‘damaged identity'; in turn, contextualising this writing in terms of international cultural processes brings into relief the complexities of the Scottish situation,
-- which included Highlands & Lowlands, Catholic & Scots Calvinist, the paradoxical oppositions in the witches' chaunt in Shakespeare's Macbeth, Robert Louis Stevenson's Dr. Jeckell & Mr. Hyde, and, primarily, Scotland as colonised & colonising, add as creatively significant Calvinism's Elect & Damned ....

Tuesday, September 05, 2006

Scots: Pronunication & Lexicon

Scots -- either a dialect or a language, according as one's Scottish nationalist tendencies go, but, alas in either case, indisputably Anglic -- features in our course texts to varying degrees of obtrusiveness. Use this post as a central hub for lexicons, guides to pronunciation, and exemplary audio clips. A perma-link is on the blog sidebar.

  1. Scottish Dialect at the BBC
  2. More Scottish Slang at the BBC
  3. Pittin the Mither Tongue on the Wab
  4. Scots Language: at ScotsIndependent.org
  5. Scots Glossary
  6. Scottish Vernacular Dictionary

Remember also that I have put some of my back copies of The Broons and Oor Wullie annuals on Course Reserve to help your familiarisation.



On Scots Calvinism, con't

Note that the unifying concept to the Calvinist dogma is Predestination, and the type of culture which it created in Scotland is known popularly (and helpfully, though strictly speaking not accurately) as Puritanism.

Calvinism: TULIP & the Bible

That (Scots) Calvinism is the ghost in the post-1945 Scottish literary machine is a commonplace: indeed, it is explict in our course fiction. We, however, need not merely acknowledge but understand this, academically. The TULIP formula given today in lecture to that end, provoked two excellent question. The first is, how does one know whether one is among the Elect or the damned? This is the crux, in my view. Short answer is, on Earth, one does not know: can not know. A fair hearing can be found at this link at the Rutgers U. site. John Calvin's answer, here from his Institutes of the Christian Religion, is the concept of "calling": if you hear the call, you are among the Elect.

In the elect, we consider calling as an evidence of election, and justification as another token of its manifestation, till they arrive in glory, which constitutes its completion. As God seals His elect by vocation and justification, so by excluding the reprobate from the knowledge of His name and the sanctification of His Spirit, He affords an indication of the judgment that awaits them.

But since Calvin elsewhere declared (& rejoiced in) the fact that God causes some Damned to think on Earth that they are Elect in order that their torment in Hell will be greater, this is merely a fudge. That being said, I note in Calvin's defense that every human system has its flaw. Calvin wanted to assert God's sovereignty and to give believers certainty in their Salvation. These two things he did -- but at the cost of removing intellectual knowledge of Salvation. We must also be mindful of avoiding the vice of chronological chauvanism: in Calvin's day, to his public, the doctrines that we find abstruse changed the world and were embraced by millions.

The question arising from lecture today was over support from scripture for the five points of Calvinist dogma. We should turn here to the Calvinists themselves: I have found this suitable link with the TULIP formula and Bible verses in support of each. It is, of course, lamentably easy to cite selectively from any text to support a favoured position; and indeed Calvin drew respondants who laid against him the evidentiary charge of omitting passages that gave a more full and a balanced soteriological picture.

To close, here, again from the Institutes, is Calvin himself on these dogmas.

In conformity, therefore, to the clear doctrine of the Scripture, we assert, that by an eternal and immutable counsel, God has once for all
determined, both whom He would admit to salvation, and whom He would condemn to destruction.

Predestination we call the eternal decree of God by which He has determined in Himself what would have to become of every individual of mankind. For they are not all created with a similar destiny; but eternal life is fore-ordained for some, and eternal damnation for others. Every man, therefore, being created for one or the other of these ends, we say, he is predestinated either to life or to death.

Virtual Course Package

The class consensus was for the use of supporting articles to be collected from online sources, supplemented by licensed photocopies. I'll use this post to contain links to those articles, & have a perma-link on the blog sidebar. Note that some of the articles will require you to authenticate to the SFU proxy server.

Michael Gardiner: Endless Enlightenment: Eye-Operated Technology and the Political Economy of Vision. (2004)

John Knox: The First Blast of the Trumpet Against the Monstrous Regiment of Women. (1558)

David Hume: The Sceptic. (1752) Of Superstition & Enthusiasm. (1777)

Friedrich Nietzsche: On the Genealogy of Morals: A Polemical Tract. (1887)

Donald McLeod: Scottish Calvinism: A Dark, Repressive Force? (2001)

Claire Colebrook: The Politics and Potential of Everyday Life. (2002)

Carole Jones: White Men on Their Backs – From Objection to Abjection:The Representation of the White Male as Victim in William McIlvanney's Docherty and Irvine Welsh's Marabou Stork Nightmares. (2006)

George Orwell: Notes on Nationalism. (1945)

Thursday Lecture

As announced in our opening class, Thursday's lecture will, in addition to the notorious John Knox treatise on women and regnancy, begin our engagement with Muriel Spark's The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie. Spark is as much a poet as a novelist, and the succintness of this novel is a function of its poetic substance: stunningly telescoped meanings; deep evocation from the briefest of passages; echoes and re-echoes of a cadence one half seen; the other half felt.
Your first reading won't take long at all. As with all first readings, read solely for pleasure, and reflect when compleated what the primary character, or characters, or central object, might have represented. Always keep in mind Dr. Johnson's famous warrant for reading without looking at, or, pertinent to us, taking, notes:
Notes are often necessary, but they are necessary evils. Let him, that is yet unacquainted with [the book at hand] .... read every [work] .... from the first .... to the last, with utter negligence of all his commentators. When his [i.e. the reader's] fancy is once on the wing, let it not stoop at correction or explanation. When his attention is strongly engaged, let it disdain alike to turn aside to the name of
Theobald and of Pope [i.e. any commentator, no matter how famous]. Let him read on through brightness and obscurity, through integrity and corruption; let him preserve his comprehension of the dialogue and his interest in the fable. And when the pleasures of novelty have ceased, let him attempt exactness, and read the commentators.
Particular passages are cleared by notes, but the general effect of the work is weakened. The mind is refrigerated by interruption; the thoughts are diverted from the principal subject; the reader is weary, he suspects not why; and at last throws away the book, which he has too diligently studied.

Sunday, September 03, 2006

Hoots, Mon

Welcome to Scottish Literature after 1945" - English 342 at Simon Fraser University, Autumn 2006: a course on Scots taught to Canadians by an Englishman. A pant, awricht....

Bagpipes, Braveheart and Beyond: Postwar Scottish Literature

“It is never difficult to distinguish between a Scotsman with a grievance and a ray of sunshine.” P. G. Wodehouse

In this course we will read five novels and one play that will serve as an introduction to postwar Scottish literature. We will explore some of the specific historical and cultural contexts of these texts, looking at the way in which writers engage with different versions of Scottish national identity. We will also examine the legacies in modern Scottish literature of Imperialism and the Scottish Enlightenment. Additional topics for discussion and research may include the following: gender in the Scottish context; humour and irony; popular culture, film and music; Gaelic and Celtic; the Gothic; the Kirk and the dirk; the great Scottish cities and the rural lowlands and highlands; and, of course, usquebaugh.
PRIMARY TEXTS
Spark, Muriel The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie
McIlvanney, William Laidlaw
Lochhead, Liz Mary Queen of Scots Got Her Head Chopped Off
Galloway, Janice The Trick is to Keep Breathing
Welsh, Irvine Trainspotting
Warner, Alan Morvern Callar
COURSE REQUIREMENTS
20% Group Field School Project
10% Participation
15% Individual research presentation
20% Mid-term essay (2000 words)
35% Final essay (3200 words)